VFD_Service_News_Post_Banner.jpg

How to Troubleshoot 5 Common VFD Problems in Water Systems

Variable frequency drives (VFDs) give water system professionals greater control over pump performance by helping maintain consistent pressure, manage motor speed, reduce energy use and control pump starts and stops. But when a VFD isn't operating as expected, understanding what the drive is telling you can make troubleshooting faster.

Five common VFD issues in water systems include:

Many VFD problems can be narrowed down by checking the drive's feedback, fault history, input signals, motor load and programming, as addressed in the VFD troubleshooting FAQ below. Knowing what can cause each problem and what to check before making changes to the system can help return the VFD to operation more quickly and prevent further issues.

1. How to Troubleshoot Analog Signal Problems for a VFD

In water systems, an analog signal provides continuous feedback that a VFD can use to control pump operation, with the electrical signal scaled based on the voltage or current signal. One of the most common examples within the water systems industry is a pressure transducer.

A typical pressure transducer may have a 0-100 psi range and a 4-20 mA output. In this configuration:

  • 4 mA represents 0 psi
  • 20 mA represents 100 psi

For the system to operate correctly, the VFD must be programmed for the range of the installed transducer.

FE_Connect_Screenshot_Landing_Page.png

Check the Pressure Transducer Scaling

Incorrect scaling can cause the pressure shown by the VFD to differ from the system's actual pressure. For example, suppose the physical pressure gauge reads 100 psi while the VFD reports 50 psi. A possible cause is that the drive has been configured for a 200 psi transducer even though a 100 psi transducer is installed. That difference isn't just a display problem. The VFD uses this feedback to determine how fast the pump should run.

If VFD’s drive set point pressure is programmed to 60 psi but reads only half the actual system pressure, it may continue increasing pump speed as the physical system pressure approaches 120 psi. To troubleshoot digital signal loss, check the Hand/Off/Auto (HOA) switch.

What to Check for Analog Signal Loss in a VFD

To start troubleshooting analog pressure loss in a VFD, review the pressure feedback displayed on the VFD or its companion application, when available; if the VFD is getting feedback from the transducer, then it is likely a programming error.

If the transducer is wired into the right terminals and the VFD is showing feedback correctly, then the analog input for the proportional integral derivative (PID) loop might be set to the incorrect analog input. If the drive is showing a lower value than expected, it could be a faulty transducer.

If there is no programming issue and no feedback is present:

  1. Check control voltage. Many VFD control boards provide 12 or 24 VDC for control circuits. If the control board shows no voltage, then it is likely a control board issue.
  2. Inspect terminal connections. If there is voltage, make sure the wire insulation is not trapped in the terminals.
  3. Confirm transducer wiring. Reversed wiring can prevent the transducer from operating.
  4. Inspect field wiring and connections. Check the wiring between the controller and transducer for damage or loose connections.
  5. Evaluate the transducer. If voltage, programming, terminals and wiring are correct, the transducer may need to be replaced.

2. What Causes Digital Signal Loss in a VFD?

Unlike an analog signal, which represents a range of values, a digital signal typically communicates an on/off or open/closed condition.

A common example is a Hand/Off/Auto (HOA) switch. The switch sends a control signal telling the drive which operating mode to use. In Auto mode, for example, the VFD may be programmed to run the pump using PID control and adjust motor speed according to pressure feedback.

Digital signal problems don't always generate a VFD fault. Instead, the drive may simply fail to perform the requested function.

X-Drive_3R_Frame 2_Interior [Training Image].png

How to Troubleshoot a Digital Input

The first steps to troubleshoot digital signal loss in a variable frequency drive is similar to analog signal loss—check the feedback on the drive to ensure the VFD acknowledges the terminal closure; if the correct signal is on the correct terminal, then the terminal is likely just not programmed correctly. If the incorrect terminal is getting closure, then it is likely just a wiring issue.

When the drive doesn't recognize the signal at all:

  1. Verify control voltage.
  2. Inspect the wiring and terminal connections.
  3. Test the switch with an ohmmeter.
  4. Check for continuity or low resistance when the switch is closed.

If the switch fails the continuity test, it may need to be replaced.

VFD_Service_News_Post_App.png

3. How to Troubleshoot a VFD Underload or Overload Fault

When a VFD reports a fault, start by checking the unit’s fault history or fault log. The fault log can show important information, including the motor amperage and operating frequency in hertz (Hz) when the fault occurred. These readings can help determine whether the fault was caused by an incorrect VFD setting or an actual pump or motor problem.

For example, a 10 HP, 6-inch, 230-volt Franklin Electric submersible motor has a full-load amperage (FLA) of 28.4A and a maximum load, or service factor amperage (SFA), of 32.2A.

A common starting point for setting underload protection is:

  • Submersible pumps: 70% of motor FLA
  • Centrifugal pumps: 50% of motor FLA

For the example motor, 70% of the 28.4A FLA is about 19.8A.

If the VFD fault history shows an underload fault at 27.5A, the motor was operating well above the recommended underload threshold. In this case, the underload protection setting may need to be adjusted closer to 19.8A.

These recommendations assume the pump and motor horsepower are properly matched, and the system is operating at full speed. If the fault occurred at 19A while the motor was running at only 45 Hz, consider adjusting the protection settings so underload detection applies when the pump is operating at full speed.

What Causes an Underload Fault in a VFD?

The pump creates the load on the motor. In general, moving more water increases motor load, while moving less water reduces it. If an underload fault continues after confirming the VFD settings are correct, look for conditions that may be reducing water flow.

Common causes of an underload fault for a variable frequency drive include:

  • A drop in the well's water level
  • The pump drawing air because the well has been over-pumped
  • A blocked suction, impeller or discharge
  • A stuck valve
  • A worn or damaged pump

4. What Causes a Motor Overload Fault or E-Thermal Fault in a VFD?

For a motor overload fault, start by checking the VFD fault history to see the amperage when the fault occurred. This can help determine whether the issue is related to programming or an actual overload condition.

When programming a VFD, the motor amperage setting is typically used to calculate overload protection. Motor amps can be set up to the motor's maximum load or SFA. If the VFD is tripping below the appropriate value, the protection setting may need to be reviewed or adjusted. Again, this assumes the pump and motor horsepower are properly matched and the system is operating at full speed.

If the settings are correct, determine what is causing the motor to draw excessive amperage, including:

  • Excessive pump flow: Changes in water level, insufficient back pressure or incorrect pump sizing can increase flow and motor load.
  • Insufficient motor cooling: Submersible motors require adequate cooling flow past the motor.
  • Incorrect voltage: Verify voltage against the motor nameplate and manufacturer requirements.
  • Current unbalance: Excessive unbalance between phases can contribute to motor heating and operating problems.
  • Mechanical drag: Problems within the pump or motor may increase the torque required to operate.
  • Motor problems: A damaged or failing motor can also produce abnormally high current.

Franklin Electric recommends maintaining current unbalance at no more than 10% when operating below FLA and no more than 5% when operating at or above FLA.

5. Why Won't a VFD-Controlled Pump Go to Sleep?

When a VFD-controlled water system reaches its pressure setpoint and demand stops, the drive should reduce pump speed and eventually enter sleep mode.

VFD_Service_News_Post_App_2.jpg

If the pump continues to run after demand stops, the issue may not be with the VFD itself, but could be:

  • System leaks
  • A leaking check valve
  • Pressure tank problems
  • Incorrect sleep settings
  • Control settings that don't respond quickly enough to changing pressure

In a properly sealed system, the VFD should bring the system to pressure, reduce output toward its minimum operating frequency and then stop the pump.

Troubleshooting VFD Sleep Problems

Start with the water system before changing drive parameters. Check for leaks, verify check valve operation and inspect the pressure tank. If leaks or pressure tank issues can be corrected, the VFD’s default sleep settings will typically operate as intended. If the system is mechanically sound but the drive still doesn't enter sleep mode, review its programming.

Depending on the VFD and application, troubleshooting sleep mode issues may include:

  • Adjusting minimum operating frequency to a pressure that will certainly build pressure
  • Setting the sleep delay low so the system will go to sleep before over-pressurizing
  • Decreasing sleep delays and raising sleep detection settings
  • Setting the proportional gain and integral time to increase the responsiveness of the pump

Use care when changing these settings. Making the drive enter sleep more aggressively can introduce other problems, including pressure fluctuations, excessive cycling or overpressure.

VFD Troubleshooting FAQ

What should you check first when a VFD faults?
Start with the VFD's fault history. Review the fault type along with motor amperage, operating frequency, pressure feedback and other available operating data at the time of the event.

Can a pressure transducer cause a VFD to operate at the wrong pressure?
Yes. Incorrect transducer scaling, wiring, programming or a failed sensor can provide inaccurate pressure feedback. Because the VFD uses that feedback to adjust pump speed, an incorrect signal can lead to incorrect system pressure.

What can cause an underload fault on a pump VFD?
Potential causes include incorrect underload settings, low well water levels, air entering the pump, restricted flow, a stuck valve, pump wear or pump damage.

What can cause a motor overload fault?
High pump flow, insufficient motor cooling, improper voltage, excessive current unbalance, mechanical drag or a motor problem can increase amperage and trigger overload protection.

Why does my VFD-controlled pump keep running instead of going to sleep?
Check for system leaks, a leaking check valve and pressure tank problems first. If the hydraulic system is operating correctly, review the VFD's minimum frequency, sleep delay, sleep detection, proportional gain and integral settings.

Disclaimer: VFD installation and service should only be performed by technically qualified personnel using the appropriate tools, equipment, and procedures. Always follow applicable national and local electrical codes, as well as all recommendations, warnings, and instructions provided with the product. Failure to do so may result in electrical shock, fire, improper operation, or equipment failure.

 

As featured in Water Well Journal's article: Quickly Service a VFD

< All News
Who We Are

Franklin Electric is a global leader in the production and marketing of systems and components for the movement of water and energy. Recognized as a technical leader in its products and services, Franklin Electric serves customers worldwide in residential, commercial, agricultural, industrial, municipal, and fueling applications. Franklin Electric is proud to be recognized in Newsweek’s lists of America’s Most Responsible Companies 2024, Most Trustworthy Companies 2024, and Greenest Companies 2025; Best Places to Work in Indiana 2024; and America’s Climate Leaders 2024 by USA Today.